Cheese Recipe
Cheddar, Yellow American, White American, Swiss, Pepperjack, or Smoked Gouda
Was this page helpful?
Help improve this recipe for others.
Send this recipe to your inbox.
We'll email it straight to you - plus weekly cooking inspiration.
Ingredients
Some product links may be affiliates. If you buy through them, you're supporting the site and Pekin may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Cheese Options (select one per burger)
Method
Cheese Preparation & Melting
Select cheese
Choose one cheese variety for each burger: Cheddar, Yellow American, White American, Swiss, Pepperjack, or Smoked Gouda. Use one standard deli or pre-sliced piece (about 20–30 g) per burger.
Melt cheese on burger
Place the cooked burger patty (hot off the grill or skillet) on the cooking surface or keep it in the pan it was cooked in over low heat. Immediately place the selected cheese slice on top of the patty so it contacts the hot surface. To achieve even, thorough melting, cover the patty loosely with a lid or a heatproof bowl for 20–45 seconds. For thicker slices like smoked Gouda or Swiss, cover for up to 45–60 seconds. Remove the lid when the cheese looks glossy and has softened and starts to drape over the edges of the patty.
Alternative quick-melt method
If you prefer very rapid melting, after placing the cheese on the patty, briefly spoon 1–2 teaspoons of hot water into the pan away from the burger and immediately cover for 10–15 seconds; steam will speed melting. Be careful to avoid splashing and only use this method on a pan, not a grill.
Assemble burger
Transfer the cheese-topped patty onto the bottom bun (toasted if desired). Add any additional toppings and place the top bun. Serve immediately so the cheese remains warm and melty.
Notes on cheese behavior
American (yellow and white) melts fastest and becomes very creamy. Cheddar melts well but may take slightly longer and become stringy when hot. Swiss softens and develops a nutty flavor; Pepperjack melts similarly to cheddar but adds spicy notes. Smoked Gouda offers a smoky aroma and becomes very creamy when warmed; slice thinly if it’s dense to help it melt more quickly.